I stopped playing for just over a year. When they were breaking some of the basics with patches, and then giving the 'working as expected' BS it was game breaking for me. However, they have fixed all of that, and with the AFK level, RNG beating Caphras it is a MUCH better experience.
I have pulled back in a few friends, and my old guild is all starting to play again. Really enjoying the new areas, quests, and remastered mode looks so good.
Graphically this game is the best MMO going. The action system I still giggle about. So fun. Back on the BDO train. Best sandbox MMO going.
Comments
My main character, also my lifeskiller, is still locked to level 49, and I quit playing a year ago.
Until they add a PvE server (and actually create PvE content that isn't just grinding mobs at varying difficulty), there's no reason to bother playing this game besides a "first time experience".
Unless you enjoy PVP of course, because that's mostly all the game is. Except it's p2w and highly gear based unlike other pvp focused games, so there's no point investing into it anyway unless you like being sub-par until you pay real money or grind your life away.
I cannot really say much as an overall opinion due to my lack of time with the game but I can say that this 'seems' like the sandbox game i've always wanted- Live your life in a fantasy world.
I got the explorers edition (*since its on sale right now) and also bought some cash shop items (a pet and an outfit) and am around $70 total spent- I really dont mind having to drop another $70 or so next month and then maintain a sub but if its too P2W i'll just play as long as I am enjoying it- And damn, I am enjoying the hell out of it atm.
I also like how there are afk activities- Its a nice way to wind down, relax and multi-task. For instance , my toon is reading right now while I grab some food, surf the web a bit and type this... He is gaining actual in-game knowledge for this afk activity. When I go to sleep for the night I'll leave my guy fishing...Its actually pretty fun to wake up and see what all you've gained/caught.
The game seems to have a ton of depth and overall I'm loving it. Wish I had decided to try this a long time ago but the P2W talk scared me away.
edit- Thus far I havnt seen a whole lot of 'kill on sight' PVP- It seems to revolve more around guild wars than just ganking. Not saying that random ganking doesnt happen but most PVP is structured from what I can see.
It might be slightly less annoying if the systems were actually fun to execute, but their not, they're boring and in my opinion senselessly designed systems to achieve some outcome, the odd and annoying favor wheel stands out for me, but most all of the systems just weren't fun to execute on. Clunky and soulless as you pointed out. I lasted about 4 weeks then all systems hit pay walls to make them partially sane to execute on, but there is no fun in any of them.
Designing games that are fun and have character are just not main focus of game design anymore.
My SWTOR referral link for those wanting to give the game a try. (Newbies get a welcome package while returning players get a few account upgrades to help with their preferred status.)
https://www.ashesofcreation.com/ref/Callaron/