What do you guys think of these speakers?

MightyUnclean

Hey guys, what do you think of these speakers?  I'm trying to keep the price under $100.  I've had Logitech before and been happy.

Thanks!


https://www.newegg.com/black-logitech-z533-wired/p/N82E16836121203?Description=pc%20speakers%20with%20sub&cm_re=pc_speakers_with_sub-_-36-121-203-_-Product&quicklink=true

Hmm, or these?

https://www.newegg.com/p/19S-00BM-00092?Description=edifer%20pc%20speakers&cm_re=edifer_pc_speakers-_-19S-00BM-00092-_-Product

Ridelynn

I have a pair of Edifier monitors on my PC. It’s not the same as what you link, but I would give a good vote of confidence for the Edifer brand.

Cleffy

Your in premium audio pricing, so you should probably pick the premium audio device. The Logitech seems a bit overpriced for something that doesn't offer optical or USB. You will be fighting a hum.
I think you can probably do better with a 20hz-40khz device in that price range, but I would need to do a bit more research. 

Amathe

Those look great to me.

Ozmodan

Personally, I would not waste money on PC speakers, you get far better audio quality with headphones and save yourself a lot of money.

Asm0deus

Jean-Luc_Picard said:

Nothing beats a dedicated home cinema receiver + speaker system on a PC though...

Pretty much this.

Ridelynn

My opinion:
I gave up on "computer" speakers a while ago. I agree about receiver + speakers, but that turns into a physically large setup fairly quickly. If you don't have the desk space or inclination to do a Receiver + Bookshelves, then go with studio monitors.

These are the speakers I have:
https://www.newegg.com/p/0S6-0051-00042?Description=edifier&cm_re=edifier-_-0S6-0051-00042-_-Product

True, they don't have a subwoofer. They also sound pretty darn good without it.

M-Audio and JBL also make (imho) good Studio Monitor speakers in the 4-6" range and $100-$500 price range.