Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Quick Links
The Importance of Story and Lore in the MMORPG
Consuetudo
Member UncommonPosts: 191
Story = The narrative your character experiences, either mandated by developers or created by you
Lore = Background information about the game world that you do not personally experience but which gives flavor to your story
I do not believe that story should be important compared to lore, yet developers seem to disagree with me. From voiceovers to heavily instanced story missions etc, MMORPGs increasingly resemble single player games with their emphasis on "story-driven gameplay."
I'm going through vanilla WoW again, and there is a story there, but it's completely optional and only matters if you want to pay attention. You can toggle slow quest text for example, but you can also have it appear instantly and not care. There is, however, tons of awesome lore that is all pervading.
I think at the heart of the MMO should be multiplayer gameplay and lore (not story). When I was younger, I was rather antisocial and played MMOs as if they were solo games, but they aren't. The experience is vastly more rewarding when you are social and encouraged to be social. I think that the focus on story takes away from the potential for player-created stories with friends.
Lore = Background information about the game world that you do not personally experience but which gives flavor to your story
I do not believe that story should be important compared to lore, yet developers seem to disagree with me. From voiceovers to heavily instanced story missions etc, MMORPGs increasingly resemble single player games with their emphasis on "story-driven gameplay."
I'm going through vanilla WoW again, and there is a story there, but it's completely optional and only matters if you want to pay attention. You can toggle slow quest text for example, but you can also have it appear instantly and not care. There is, however, tons of awesome lore that is all pervading.
I think at the heart of the MMO should be multiplayer gameplay and lore (not story). When I was younger, I was rather antisocial and played MMOs as if they were solo games, but they aren't. The experience is vastly more rewarding when you are social and encouraged to be social. I think that the focus on story takes away from the potential for player-created stories with friends.
Post edited by Consuetudo on
Comments
But when grouped, more often then not the focus is on go go go, click through, click through, hurry hurry. There is no way to enjoy a story under those conditions.
Every story in a group setting is the same. Group of people go into some enclosed space, hurried through, avoided colored circles and got loots.
EQ1, EQ2, SWG, SWTOR, GW, GW2 CoH, CoV, FFXI, WoW, CO, War,TSW and a slew of free trials and beta tests
If you enjoy the stories what this did is made group content - which I agree that it is the purpose of MMORPGS - a pain in the butt making you feel like you were missing out on a lot of flavor and context. This more than anything else discouraged grouping.
And yes, I want there to be well written deep context and lore told throughout the game. That to me feels a whole lot more enjoyable than "go kill 1000 things 'cause that's how you level." That's the difference between an MMORPG that feels like a world and one that feels like just a game that could be happening anywhere for any old gamey reason.
“Microtransactions? In a single player role-playing game? Are you nuts?”
― CD PROJEKT RED
But seriously, without story, you can't have NPCs that are anything but robots. Without story or NPCs you can't have any NPC cultures, history, non-human biology, or other lore. Without all that your 'virtual world' is just a sandbox. We have several sandboxes already, how different can a new one be when the only variance is the appearance of the plants and what exactly you can craft?
The problem with moderns MMORPGs is that the story writing is generally pretty awful. Filled with tropes and cliches (which can sometimes work, don't get me wrong) the story in most MMOs often isn't worth reading, even if you're interested in storylines and deeper lore. When it becomes a chore, and is just something to skip through, it misses the point and reason for existing in the first place. I should also point out that we as gamers have come a long way as well and our standards for a good storyline have increased a lot since WoW.
- Finally, story comes to MMORPGs via expansions. Each new expansion tells a new story of the world, with major events changing the world (sometimes drastically). The actual story tends to be a non-participatory event that happens followed by a bunch of new single-player quests.
I'd like to see a bit more mechanics above the single player mode, as that tends to encourage solo play. Group-oriented quests are perhaps the most viable method to improve the game's story, but pretty much need to consider things such as concurrency (who has this quest), synchronization (who's on what step of the quest), duration (how long does the quest take), and frequency (lockout and/or initiation timers). Something like LDoN missions from EQ1 are a good possibility that could be used for group-focused stories.The third and fourth require significant commitment from the developers, to develop tools or hire personnel to run the events fairly. These have more promise, but I don't know of any company willing to take the steps necessary to enact these on a regular basis. In my aborted game idea from 2002, I had wanted to build an RTS-like interface into the game (server-side) to allow staff to control creatures and script events in the game dynamically.
I expect expansions will continue to be the mechanism to deliver the broad-sweeping stories to the game world, even if all the 'story' happens off-camera. They are probably the easiest to monetize, and accommodates all business models.
Logic, my dear, merely enables one to be wrong with great authority.
As to a mmorpg,i want the LORE and not so much a story to tell,the story should be our own that we develop by playing in the world with other real players.I don't want soooo much that it becomes a mess with LORE flying all over the place but a nice neat tidy package that holds true throughout the entire game.
Example,i felt EQ2 lacked the story/Lore,yeah there is Antonia Bayle,there are many languages but i never once got the feeling i was part of any culture within the world.This is why linear questing is so bad,the entire focus becomes a player with blinkers on vee lining directly to each "?"over npc heads.
On the flip side,in FFXI my fave game,the LORE was supported FOREVER,throughout the game.Example everyone is against the Beast hordes,even the Beastmaster class can't charm them ,everything except the Beastmen.The Beastmen reside all over the world,they have strongholds/castles and the game even uses an invasion by the Beastmen tribes onto cities that players defend and it is like that all over the game.
So i want to see a noticeable LORE structure behind the races and the world.Quests should be for fame and fortune,to honor your realm and NOT to manufacture xp gains.Quests can support the fight against the enemy hordes and bring players together to fight them off.
I also do not like developers that feel the need to tel me the story,if i can't see the LORE and the background inside of the game,you did a crap job with the game design.
Never forget 3 mile Island and never trust a government official or company spokesman.
I do enjoy good stories in games.
"We all do the best we can based on life experience, point of view, and our ability to believe in ourselves." - Naropa "We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are." SR Covey
The problem is the change to leveling with the removal of much of multiplayer content and make it more and more about soloing up to level cap. The quick and simple path to level cap is what "ruins" mmorpg.
I don't personaly care how story driven the content is. I hope all content is segregated so people want to solo or people only want to group won't be forced to do it.
Suspension of disbelief - I am unable to do this with stories in computer games. The story might be really great, but it NEVER matches up with my actions as a player. Literally never. I have the story telling me one thing, but my actions are telling me something else. This results in a really jarring experience, it invalidates the story and just ends up wasting my time. I am unable to suspend my disbelief and enjoy two opposing things at the same time.
Poor Writing - I am a fairly prolific reader, probably read one book a week for pleasure and almost exclusively read fantasy and sci-fi. Due to this, I cannot accept the poor writing that you get in computer games. It's just really awful guys. SW:TOR is often praised for it's stories, but seriously?! They sucked! The overwhelming majority were just really basic and generic, I just cannot understand how people thought they were good?!
Time Distortion - The passage of time in a story almost never matches the passage of time in game. The story will be telling me that one thing follows another, but in reality I just spent 3 hours exploring those hills, or farming that dungeon. This is made particularly worse in MMOs where the game world is persistent and thus time is always passing, but the story stays static and time only moves inside the story when I'm actively engaging with the story.
Clash With Multiplayer - stories do not work in a multiplayer environment. Stories are told in a linear fashion (questing), so in a multiplayer environment I can only participate in the story with my friends if they are at the exact same point as me. This segregates the community into tiny chunks, preventing multiplayer from happening. Then there is the clash in actions - the story being told is usually personal, making you the hero or asking you to do specific tasks, yet as soon as I discuss such things with other players you realise you aren't the hero, everyone is, therefore nobody is. Story and multiplayer just never works out well.
Despite my strong dislike for stories in computer games, I'm not completely against them. My preference in an MMORPG is to use strong lore to setup the context of the world. For example, putting in lore to explain the sith and the jedi, as well as republic and empire, and giving a strong background for the conflicts is great. But, let us then live that conflict through our own actions, rather than have the conflict dictated to us through cutscenes and poorly written quests.
If you do want to have actual stories, rather than background lore, my first requirement is to remove all XP from the quests. I think unlinking story and progression is vital. That way, those participating in the story are definitely there for the story, and not because they've been forced there. Second, it makes the story more accessible to a wider range of people, so grouping up and playing the story with friends is easier. Finally, it means the writers don't have to write 1000 generic stories for quests, they can instead focus on creating just 10 great quest chains with engaging stories.
Now that doesn’t mean it has to be canned voiceovers or quest givers with question marks. Player developed story is just fine...
But their needs to be a purpose... a backdrop to your activity. Otherwise you can just play one of those idle adventures games.
All time classic MY NEW FAVORITE POST! (Keep laying those bricks)
"I should point out that no other company has shipped out a beta on a disc before this." - Official Mortal Online Lead Community Moderator
Proudly wearing the Harbinger badge since Dec 23, 2017.
Coined the phrase "Role-Playing a Development Team" January 2018
"Oddly Slap is the main reason I stay in these forums." - Mystichaze April 9th 2018
Also how about being able to play the video as soon as you pick up the quest? Eventually you all get together to do the quest but even have all seen it by the time you are ready to start.
"True friends stab you in the front." | Oscar Wilde
"I need to finish" - Christian Wolff: The Accountant
Just trying to live long enough to play a new, released MMORPG, playing New Worlds atm
Fools find no pleasure in understanding but delight in airing their own opinions. Pvbs 18:2, NIV
Don't just play games, inhabit virtual worlds™
"This is the most intelligent, well qualified and articulate response to a post I have ever seen on these forums. It's a shame most people here won't have the attention span to read past the second line." - Anon
I think the best kind of story is a subtle one. The movie playing a fake advertisement on the wall describing a little about what the universe is like or the collect-able piece of lore hidden in a nook or cranny with an intriguing and unexpected tale from an individual's perspective. Those kinds of things add up to a whole lot of atmosphere in my experience.
I like a good background story to set the 'tone' for the game world but after that it should be up to the players to create their own story in a MMORPG imo. I don't enjoy forced, scripted story and voice-overs interrupting gameplay.
I love story for single player games.
If I can become a unique part of the world story through gameplay and story arcs allow me to integrate my role into the MMO, then I like it.
"We all do the best we can based on life experience, point of view, and our ability to believe in ourselves." - Naropa "We don't see things as they are, we see them as we are." SR Covey